The title is from the testimony of Amanda Tyler before the January 6 committee. She is part of a group called Christians Against Christian Nationalism (see video below). I have transcribed most of her testimony (also below) so you can follow along if you so desire.
The reason I have posted this, especially after such a long time of not posting, is because I am concerned about the current majority on our city council in Huntington Beach. There are a lot of moving parts to this concern, but Ms. Tyler’s testimony brings together these moving parts and crystalizes why I’m concerned.
-The current majority was touted as “real republicans” and “God’s government”
-A local pastor prayed at a rally that people’s hearts would be changed to vote for the “four”
-One of the members of the majority of four, now the mayor pro tem, used to have a YouTube channel where she posted videos of herself participating in various Proud Boys’ efforts. She has never apologized for or explained her involvement, only offering that she was “learning” by going to these events.
-When asked if the Holocaust occurred, her response was, “I’m researching.”
-I have personally heard one of her major backers and persons responsible for elevating her make racist and anti-Semitic statements.
-Another member of the majority of four had QAnon statements on his campaign page.
– Another member of the majority was charged with 16 money laundering charges and agreed to pay a $40,000 fine, negotiated down from $80,000 if he admitted wrongdoing.
In addition, since winning election, these “God’s government” four have conducted themselves in a bullying and vengeful manner, reversing policy simply for the sake of reversing what a previous council put in place, being condescending and denigratory toward the “liberal” minority on the council, appearing many times to be hypocritical in their proposals, and regularly limiting comments and discussion. Certainly not Godly behavior. Recently, they wanted to change the policy toward the invocation offered during the council meeting. Many understand this to be an effort designed to specifically shut out a rabbi who previously offered an invocation during the council meeting who they felt was “too political”, and at the same time, make a pastor who held rallies for them during the campaign to be able to offer the invocation. And while the other three of the four may not have any direct association with white supremacy groups, they go along tacitly supporting the one that has. While the dots may not be in a straight line, they are still easy to connect and I fear the city is on the cusp of some very ugly things to come. As Ms. Tyler notes, like other Christians across the nation, I am alarmed at how Christian nationalism and white supremacy has gained a foothold, and here in Huntington Beach, on the dais.
Transcription:
Christian nationalism is a political ideology and cultural framework that seeks to merge American and Christian identities. It suggests that “real Americans” are Christian and that “true Christians” hold a particular set of political beliefs.
The Christian in Christian nationalism is more about ethno-national identity than religion. Christian nationalism is a gross distortion of the Christian faith that I and many others hold dear. Opposition to Christian nationalism is not opposition to Christianity, and a growing number of Christians feel a religious imperative to stand against Christian nationalism.
Christian nationalism uses the language, symbols and imagery of Christianity. In fact, it may look and sound like Christianity to the casual observer. However, closer examination reveals that it uses the veneer of Christianity to point to not Jesus the Christ, but to a political figure, party or ideology.
Christian nationalism often overlaps with and provides cover for white supremacy and racial subjugation. It creates and perpetuates a sense of cultural belonging, but is limited to certain people associated with the founding of the United States, namely native-born white Christians. Christian nationalism is not patriotism. Patriotism is a healthy love of country. Nationalism is an allegiance to country that demands supremacy over all other allegiances. Christian nationalism relies on a cherry-picked and misleading version of American history in order to thrive. The Christian nation myth must downplay or ignore the role of indigenous communities, Black Americans, immigrant populations, religious minorities, secular Americans and all others who undercut the false narrative that the U.S. is special because it was founded by and for white Christians.
But the myth of a Christian nation is worse than just bad history. It undermines and contradicts the U.S. Constitution, specifically the prohibition in Article VI against religious tests for public office, one of the truly revolutionary aspects of the Constitution that laid the foundation for the U.S. being a faith freedom nation.
As a Baptist, I became a leader in the fight against Christian nationalism because of my increasing alarm about the violence it has inspired at our country’s houses of worship: Mother Emanuel AME Church in Charleston, Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh, Chabad of Poway near San Diego. As recently as earlier this year, at the top supermarket in Buffalo, Christian nationalism inspired white supremacist violence in public spaces. Christian nationalism helped fuel the attack on the U.S. Capitol on January 6th, uniting disparate actors and infusing their political cause with religious fervor. We applaud this committee’s sustained work to confront white supremacy and investigate its myriad causes. Understanding Christian nationalism is imperative to both dismantling white supremacy and preserving religious freedom for all.
Christianity does not unite Americans. Our belonging in American society must never depend on how we worship, what we believe, or how we identify religiously. Do not allow anyone to say that confronting Christian nationalism is somehow anti-Christian. All across this country, Christians are deeply alarmed by this ideology, especially the way it gives an illusion of respectability to white supremacy and undermines our nation’s foundational commitment to ensure religious freedom for all.